Get a proposal

Blog / SEO and AI search

Best AthenaHQ Alternatives: 7 Compared

The short answer

Otterly suits Low-cost AEO checks for small teams, Peec AI suits daily tracking with unlimited seats, and Profound suits tracking plus AI content generation. AthenaHQ pricing: $295 a month (self-serve, as reported in comparison pages). Otterly pricing: From $29 a month (Lite, 20 prompts). Peec AI pricing: From $95 a month (Starter, 50 prompts). 1 of the 7 alternatives have a free plan.

Why look for a AthenaHQ alternative

AthenaHQ uses a credit-based system: one credit is spent each time you take an action, such as analysing an AI prompt response for a specific model or drafting content. Its self-serve plan is listed at $295 a month in comparison pages from Profound and Scrunch, with 3,500 credits a month, and its Enterprise plan is custom-priced. It also offers AI-generated content capabilities for drafting briefs, outlines and full articles, plus a free audit and a discounted first month at $95. AthenaHQ fits a team that wants monitoring, auditing, optimization and content drafting in one platform, and that is comfortable with credits rather than a prompt count. AthenaHQ's own pricing was not publicly shown on 14 November 2026, so the $295 figure comes from comparison pages, not the vendor, and credit-based pricing makes the real monthly cost hard to predict before you start spending credits. Skip AthenaHQ if you need a published price on the vendor's own site before buying. Profound and Peec AI both publish theirs. The Essentials plan includes 3,600 credits a month, one-month credit rollover, prompt and response analysis, content recommendations, and an Athena AI agent. Athena HQ fits a team that wants the tool to tell it what to do, not just what happened. Its recommendation engine, on-page and off-page action lists, smart robots.txt and llms.txt management, and self-learning content improvement aim at closing the gap between measurement and change. The weakness is pricing transparency: the pricing page shows plan structures and credit allowances but no dollar figures, so you cannot budget without a sales conversation.

People usually switch for one of three reasons: the price at their size, a limit on the plan they are on, or a feature that sits on a higher tier. AthenaHQ's own figures, for reference: starting price $295 a month (self-serve, as reported in comparison pages); free plan: No, free audit and discounted first month.

AthenaHQ Alternatives at a glance

#PickBest forStarting priceFree plan
1OtterlyLow-cost AEO checks for small teamsFrom $29 a month (Lite, 20 prompts)Yes, free tier; 7-day free trial
2Peec AIDaily tracking with unlimited seatsFrom $95 a month (Starter, 50 prompts)No
3ProfoundTracking plus AI content generationFrom $99 a month (Starter, 50 prompts)No
4ScrunchMonitoring plus site audits and fixesFrom $250 a month (Core, 125 prompts)No, 7-day free trial
5AmICitedMonitoring tied to revenueFrom €50 a month billed monthly (Starter)No, 7-day free trial
6GoodieBrands that want tracking wired to optimisation actions$295 per month, Core, 110 promptsNo free plan; 7-day free trial on Core
7RankscaleLow-cost daily AI answer trackingFrom $20 a month ($17 a month billed annually, yearly only)No

How we chose

These are the products that Adziq compares side by side with AthenaHQ in Best AEO Checking Tools Compared: Features, Pricing and Best Fit, 7 Best AI Search Monitoring Tools for Your Brand and 7 Best GEO Tools for Ecommerce: Prices and Picks. Prices and free-plan details were read from each vendor's pricing page and last checked on 2026-11-14. No hands-on testing was done. The order is not a ranking by price.

Otterly: best for Low-cost AEO checks for small teams

Starting priceFrom $29 a month (Lite, 20 prompts)
Best forLow-cost AEO checks for small teams
Skip ifyou need more than 20 prompts and your budget is under $189 a month
Otterly website homepage screenshot
Screenshot of the Otterly homepage.

Otterly.AI is the lowest-priced entry point in this category by a wide margin. Standard costs $189 a month for 160 prompts, and Premium costs $489 a month for 535 prompts. A free tier and a 7-day trial are available, annual billing saves 15%, and every plan includes all 7 engines, so you choose how many prompts to track rather than which engines to drop. Otterly.AI fits a small team or solo marketer taking a first serious look at AI search. Twenty prompts covers a focused niche and little else, and the step to Standard at $189 a month is a sixfold jump for 160 prompts. Skip Otterly.AI if you need more than 20 prompts and your budget is under $189 a month.

Starting price: From $29 a month (Lite, 20 prompts). Free plan: Yes, free tier; 7-day free trial. Skip if you need more than 20 prompts and your budget is under $189 a month.

Peec AI: best for daily tracking with unlimited seats

Starting priceFrom $95 a month (Starter, 50 prompts)
Best forDaily tracking with unlimited seats
Skip ifyou need more than 50 prompts and your budget is under $245 a month
Peec AI website homepage screenshot
Screenshot of the Peec AI homepage.

Peec AI is the value pick at the 50-prompt level. Starter costs $95 a month for 50 prompts across 3 models, with daily tracking, 1 project and unlimited users. Pro costs $245 a month for 150 prompts and 2 projects, and Advanced costs $495 a month for 350 prompts and 5 projects. Peec AI fits a marketing team that wants daily tracking without counting seats. Unlimited users on every plan means the whole team can read the same dashboard without a per-seat charge, and daily tracking catches fast-moving changes in AI answers. Starter covers one project, so an agency or a company with several brands needs Pro at $245 a month, and tracking more than 50 prompts means the same jump. Skip Peec AI if you need more than 50 prompts and your budget is under $245 a month. Scrunch covers 125 prompts for $250 a month. Annual billing takes 15% off the monthly rates. Starter therefore produces about 4,500 AI answers a month.

Starting price: From $95 a month (Starter, 50 prompts). Free plan: No. Skip if you need more than 50 prompts and your budget is under $245 a month.

Profound: best for tracking plus AI content generation

Starting priceFrom $99 a month (Starter, 50 prompts)
Best forTracking plus AI content generation
Skip ifyou only track ChatGPT and your budget is under $99 a month
Profound website homepage screenshot
Screenshot of the Profound homepage.

Profound is the best-known name in AI visibility, and its pricing now starts far lower than its enterprise reputation suggests. Profound fits a team that wants tracking and fixing in one place. Growth adds content generation and optimization, so the same tool that shows you are missing from an answer can draft the content meant to earn the citation. Otterly.AI covers 7 engines for $29 a month. Profound fits a larger company that wants AI search insight folded into an agent that does marketing work, not a standalone tracker.

Starting price: From $99 a month (Starter, 50 prompts). Free plan: No. Skip if you only track ChatGPT and your budget is under $99 a month.

Scrunch: best for monitoring plus site audits and fixes

Starting priceFrom $250 a month (Core, 125 prompts)
Best forMonitoring plus site audits and fixes
Skip ifyour budget is under $250 a month
Scrunch website homepage screenshot
Screenshot of the Scrunch homepage.

Scrunch goes further than monitoring: it is an Agent Experience Platform that also diagnoses, optimizes and delivers content to AI agents. Enterprise is custom-priced and covers 9 AI platforms, full site audits and custom response volumes. Scrunch fits a brand that wants the fix, not just the score. Its site audit finds rendering issues that stop AI engines citing a page, and its agent experience layer serves an optimized version of your content to AI traffic. At $250 a month, Core costs more than Profound Starter and Peec AI Starter combined, and it covers only four engines. Skip Scrunch if your budget is under $250 a month. Otterly.AI covers 7 engines for $29 a month, and Peec AI covers 50 prompts for $95. The prompt manager, citation tracking and insights dashboard are included on Core. Scrunch AI fits a team that wants the analysis to end in a fix.

Starting price: From $250 a month (Core, 125 prompts). Free plan: No, 7-day free trial. Skip if your budget is under $250 a month.

AmICited: best for monitoring tied to revenue

Starting priceFrom €50 a month billed monthly (Starter)
Best forMonitoring tied to revenue
Skip ifyou need more than 50 credits a month, since Starter covers 50 credits
AmICited website homepage screenshot
Screenshot of the AmICited homepage.

AmICited fits an ecommerce or SaaS team that wants to know whether AI visibility turns into money. Starter costs €50 a month billed monthly for 50 credits, up to 3,000 AI answers a month, one domain, 200 prompts per domain, and 10 competitors. Pro costs €120 a month for 120 credits, five domains, and 8,000 answers, with Search Console, GA4, ads, and ecommerce integrations. Premium costs €500 a month for 500 credits, 50 domains, and 33,000 answers, with white-label reporting. Every plan includes a 7-day free trial with one domain, three prompts, and three competitors, though a card is required. The weakness is the credit maths on Starter: agent runs and article generation cost extra credits, so heavy use of the AI Studio tools drains the allowance.

Starting price: From €50 a month billed monthly (Starter). Free plan: No, 7-day free trial. Skip if you need more than 50 credits a month, since Starter covers 50 credits.

Goodie: best for brands that want tracking wired to optimisation actions

Starting price$295 per month, Core, 110 prompts
Best forBrands that want tracking wired to optimisation actions
Skip ifyour budget is under $295 a month or you need SKU-level tracking on the entry plan
Goodie website homepage screenshot
Screenshot of the Goodie homepage.

Goodie's Core plan costs $295 a month for 110 prompts across five models, with a 7-day free trial, and Pro costs $999 a month for 250 prompts across eight models. Goodie tracks product visibility inside AI shopping experiences, and its AEO Writer drafts AI-optimised content from the gaps it finds, with 50 optimisations a month on Core. Pro adds SKU-level commerce visibility, which suits brands that sell products through AI shopping surfaces. Core covers one brand and two countries and languages, with unlimited seats. Skip Goodie if your budget is under $295 a month or you need SKU-level tracking on the entry plan, because that sits on Pro.

Starting price: $295 per month, Core, 110 prompts. Free plan: No free plan; 7-day free trial on Core. Skip if your budget is under $295 a month or you need SKU-level tracking on the entry plan. Full details are in 6 Best LLM SEO Tracking Software Tools.

Rankscale: best for low-cost daily AI answer tracking

Starting priceFrom $20 a month ($17 a month billed annually, yearly only)
Best forLow-cost daily AI answer tracking
Skip ifyou need more than 480 AI answers a month, since Essentials covers 480
Rankscale website homepage screenshot
Screenshot of the Rankscale homepage.

Rankscale fits a team that wants the cheapest live monitor and is willing to track weekly rather than daily. Essentials costs $20 a month billed monthly, or $17 a month on annual billing, with 120 credits a month, up to 480 AI answers, two brand dashboard slots, and 10 page audits a month. Scheduling runs from hourly to monthly on every plan. The entry plan covers 17 or more engines and includes page audits, which no other tool at this price offers. Essentials covers 480 answers a month, so 20 prompts checked daily on one engine already uses about 620 answers. Scheduling runs from hourly to monthly, so you can check a small prompt set often or a large set rarely, and unused credits roll over up to twice the monthly allowance from Pro upward. It is yearly only, with no credit rollover, no team workspaces and no data exports, and sentiment analysis is not included.

Starting price: From $20 a month ($17 a month billed annually, yearly only). Free plan: No. Skip if you need more than 480 AI answers a month, since Essentials covers 480.

Which AthenaHQ alternative fits which need

  • Low-cost AEO checks for small teams: Otterly, From $29 a month (Lite, 20 prompts).
  • Daily tracking with unlimited seats: Peec AI, From $95 a month (Starter, 50 prompts).
  • Tracking plus AI content generation: Profound, From $99 a month (Starter, 50 prompts).
  • Monitoring plus site audits and fixes: Scrunch, From $250 a month (Core, 125 prompts).
  • Monitoring tied to revenue: AmICited, From €50 a month billed monthly (Starter).
  • Brands that want tracking wired to optimisation actions: Goodie, $295 per month, Core, 110 prompts.
  • Low-cost daily AI answer tracking: Rankscale, From $20 a month ($17 a month billed annually, yearly only).

Free plans and trials

AthenaHQ: No, free audit and discounted first month. The alternatives:

  • Otterly: Yes, free tier; 7-day free trial.
  • Peec AI: No.
  • Profound: No.
  • Scrunch: No, 7-day free trial.
  • AmICited: No, 7-day free trial.
  • Goodie: No free plan; 7-day free trial on Core.
  • Rankscale: No.

What to check before you choose

The same five checks apply to every tool on this page, and they matter more than the starting price.

  • Price per tracked prompt. These tools price by prompts, answers or credits. Divide the monthly price by the prompts you can track to compare tools fairly.
  • Which AI engines are covered. Coverage of ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Copilot varies by tool and by plan, and some engines cost extra.
  • How often answers are checked. AI answers change from run to run. Daily checks give a steadier trend than weekly ones, at a higher price.
  • What you can do with the data. Look for cited sources, competitor comparison and guidance on which pages to change, not only a visibility score.
  • Countries, languages and seats. Check how many markets, brands and users the plan includes if you work across regions or clients.

What switching from AthenaHQ involves

Switching AI visibility trackers means starting a new baseline. Export your prompt list, tags, competitor set and as much answer and citation history as the tool allows, because the new tool cannot recreate past results. Load the same prompts into the new tool and run both side by side for two to four weeks. Scores will differ, since each tool samples engines differently, so compare the direction of the trend and the sources cited, not the absolute numbers. Rebuild alerts and reports once you trust the new figures. If you are on an annual contract with AthenaHQ, check the renewal date and notice period first.

Mistakes to avoid

Do not switch on headline price alone. The starting prices here use different units (per user, per contact, per site), so price each alternative at your own usage, and check which features sit on the plan you would actually buy.

Quick answers

Otterly vs Peec AI: which one should you choose?

Otterly is the better fit for low-cost AEO checks for small teams. Peec AI is the better fit for daily tracking with unlimited seats. Otterly pricing: From $29 a month (Lite, 20 prompts). Peec AI pricing: From $95 a month (Starter, 50 prompts).

Which of these alternatives has a free plan?

Otterly offers a free plan. Scrunch, AmICited and Goodie offer a free trial instead. Checked 14 November 2026.

How much does Otterly cost?

Otterly pricing: From $29 a month (Lite, 20 prompts). Free plan: Yes, free tier; 7-day free trial. Checked 14 November 2026 against the vendor's own page.

How much does Peec AI cost?

Peec AI pricing: From $95 a month (Starter, 50 prompts). Checked 14 November 2026 against the vendor's own page.

How much does Profound cost?

Profound pricing: From $99 a month (Starter, 50 prompts). Checked 14 November 2026 against the vendor's own page.

Which alternative is best for tracking plus AI content generation?

Profound. Pricing: From $99 a month (Starter, 50 prompts). Skip if you only track ChatGPT and your budget is under $99 a month.

Which alternative is best for monitoring plus site audits and fixes?

Scrunch. Pricing: From $250 a month (Core, 125 prompts). Free plan: No, 7-day free trial. Skip if your budget is under $250 a month.

Which alternative is best for monitoring tied to revenue?

AmICited. Pricing: From €50 a month billed monthly (Starter). Free plan: No, 7-day free trial. Skip if you need more than 50 credits a month, since Starter covers 50 credits.

What is the catch with the Otterly free plan?

The free plan covers: free tier; 7-day free trial. Paid pricing: From $29 a month (Lite, 20 prompts). Checked 14 November 2026.

Common questions

What is the best alternative to AthenaHQ?

It depends on what you need. Otterly suits Low-cost AEO checks for small teams, Peec AI suits daily tracking with unlimited seats, and Profound suits tracking plus AI content generation.

How much does AthenaHQ cost?

AthenaHQ pricing: $295 a month (self-serve, as reported in comparison pages). Free plan: No, free audit and discounted first month. Checked 2026-11-14 against the vendor's page.

Is there a free alternative to AthenaHQ?

Yes. Otterly has a free plan. Check the limits before you rely on one.

How were these AthenaHQ alternatives chosen?

They are the products Adziq already compares alongside AthenaHQ, with prices read from each vendor's pricing page.

Did Adziq test these products?

No. This comparison uses each vendor's published pricing and documentation, checked on the dates shown.

Sources

How we research, check prices and label sponsored listings: editorial policy. To feature a product or agency, ask about a listing.

Tell us what you sell and who buys it.

You get a written proposal with channels, budget and what to expect in the first 90 days.

Get a proposal