The short answer
AthenaHQ suits teams that want to test with their own data before paying, Otterly suits small brands tracking a few prompts cheaply, and Peec AI suits marketing teams that want daily tracking across three engines. Goodie pricing: $295 per month, Core, 110 prompts. AthenaHQ pricing: $295 per month, Starter, 3,600 credits. Otterly pricing: $29 per month, Lite, 15 prompts ($25 per month, billed annually). 1 of the 5 alternatives have a free plan.
Why look for a Goodie alternative
Goodie's Core plan costs $295 a month for 110 prompts across five models, with a 7-day free trial, and Pro costs $999 a month for 250 prompts across eight models. Goodie tracks product visibility inside AI shopping experiences, and its AEO Writer drafts AI-optimised content from the gaps it finds, with 50 optimisations a month on Core. Pro adds SKU-level commerce visibility, which suits brands that sell products through AI shopping surfaces. Core covers one brand and two countries and languages, with unlimited seats. Skip Goodie if your budget is under $295 a month or you need SKU-level tracking on the entry plan, because that sits on Pro.
People usually switch for one of three reasons: the price at their size, a limit on the plan they are on, or a feature that sits on a higher tier. Goodie's own figures, for reference: starting price $295 per month, Core, 110 prompts; free plan: No free plan; 7-day free trial on Core.
Goodie Alternatives at a glance
| # | Pick | Best for | Starting price | Free plan |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Teams that want to test with their own data before paying | $295 per month, Starter, 3,600 credits | Yes, Essential free tier with a $25 credit | |
| 2 | Small brands tracking a few prompts cheaply | $29 per month, Lite, 15 prompts ($25 per month, billed annually) | No free plan; free trial offered | |
| 3 | Marketing teams that want daily tracking across three engines | $95 per month, Starter, 50 prompts ($80 per month, billed annually) | No free plan; free trial offered | |
| 4 | Brands that want enterprise-grade analytics and content actions | Pricing on request | No free plan; free trial of 50 prompts for 7 days | |
| 5 | Teams that want monitoring plus AI crawler analytics | $250 per month, Core, billed annually ($300 per month, billed monthly) | No free plan; 7-day free trial |
How we chose
These are the products that Adziq compares side by side with Goodie in 6 Best LLM SEO Tracking Software Tools. Prices and free-plan details were read from each vendor's pricing page and last checked on 2026-11-14. No hands-on testing was done. The order is not a ranking by price.
AthenaHQ: best for teams that want to test with their own data before paying

AthenaHQ uses a credit-based system: one credit is spent each time you take an action, such as analysing an AI prompt response for a specific model or drafting content. Starter adds on-page and off-page actions, a content optimisation agent, and a smart robots.txt and llms.txt manager. The credit model needs care: 50 prompts across 4 engines is 200 responses per run, so 3,600 credits fund about 18 runs a month, which fits weekly checks but not daily ones. Skip AthenaHQ if you need daily tracking and your budget is under $295 a month. AthenaHQ fits a team that wants monitoring, auditing, optimization and content drafting in one platform, and that is comfortable with credits rather than a prompt count. Skip AthenaHQ if you need a published price on the vendor's own site before buying. Profound and Peec AI both publish theirs. The Essentials plan includes 3,600 credits a month, one-month credit rollover, prompt and response analysis, content recommendations, and an Athena AI agent. Athena HQ fits a team that wants the tool to tell it what to do, not just what happened. AthenaHQ turns monitoring into assigned work.
Starting price: $295 per month, Starter, 3,600 credits. Free plan: Yes, Essential free tier with a $25 credit. Skip if you need daily tracking and your budget is under $295 a month.
Otterly: best for small brands tracking a few prompts cheaply

Otterly's Lite plan costs $29 a month for 15 prompts, or $25 a month billed annually, with Standard at $189 a month for 100 prompts and Premium at $489 a month for 400 prompts. A Lite subscriber who wants all seven engines pays $76 a month, not $29. Otterly.AI is the lowest-priced entry point in this category by a wide margin. Otterly.AI fits a small team or solo marketer taking a first serious look at AI search. One credit is one prompt checked once on one engine, and a prompt tracked daily on one engine uses 31 credits a month. Standard adds API and MCP access and Agent Analytics.
Starting price: $29 per month, Lite, 15 prompts ($25 per month, billed annually). Free plan: No free plan; free trial offered. Skip if you need Claude, Gemini, or Google AI Mode without paying for add-ons.
Peec AI: best for marketing teams that want daily tracking across three engines

Peec AI's Starter plan costs $95 a month, or $80 a month billed annually, for 50 prompts, with Pro at $245 a month for 150 prompts and Advanced at $495 a month for 350 prompts. Skip Peec if your budget is under $95 a month or you need more than three engines on the entry plan. Annual billing takes 15% off the monthly rates. Peec AI counts usage in AI answers: prompts times active models times tracking days. Starter therefore produces about 4,500 AI answers a month. The reporting is the reason to pick Peec AI. Visibility, position, sentiment and share of voice sit beside the domains and URLs the answers cite, plus gap analysis and recommended actions. Peec AI is the value pick at the 50-prompt level.
Starting price: $95 per month, Starter, 50 prompts ($80 per month, billed annually). Free plan: No free plan; free trial offered. Skip if your budget is under $95 a month or you need more than 3 engines on the entry plan.
Profound: best for brands that want enterprise-grade analytics and content actions

Profound publishes no entry price on its pricing page: the live page lists a free trial and custom Enterprise pricing, with an Agency Growth plan for agencies priced per client workspace. A free trial covers 50 prompts run daily for 7 days. Older reports listed a $99 Starter plan and a $399 Growth plan, but neither appears on the current page, so ask Profound for a written quote before budgeting. Skip Profound if you need a published price before talking to sales. Profound fits a team that wants tracking and fixing in one place. Growth adds content generation and optimization, so the same tool that shows you are missing from an answer can draft the content meant to earn the citation. Profound fits a larger company that wants AI search insight folded into an agent that does marketing work, not a standalone tracker. Its answer engine insights cover how your brand and competitors appear across AI platforms, and its agent analytics track AI-sourced traffic and attribution. Profound fits a large company that wants monitoring inside a wider AI marketing system rather than a standalone tracker.
Starting price: Pricing on request. Free plan: No free plan; free trial of 50 prompts for 7 days. Skip if you need a published price before talking to sales.
Scrunch: best for teams that want monitoring plus AI crawler analytics

Scrunch's Core plan costs $250 a month billed annually, or $300 a month billed monthly, with a 7-day free trial. What sets Scrunch apart is the second side of the product: it shows AI bot crawl data, including GPTBot, ClaudeBot, and PerplexityBot frequency and most-crawled pages, and attributes human visits from AI engines through a GA4 integration. Higher tiers add more engines, API access, and the Agent Experience Platform, which serves AI-optimised page versions to LLM crawlers. Scrunch goes further than monitoring: it is an Agent Experience Platform that also diagnoses, optimizes and delivers content to AI agents. Scrunch fits a brand that wants the fix, not just the score. Its site audit finds rendering issues that stop AI engines citing a page, and its agent experience layer serves an optimized version of your content to AI traffic. The prompt manager, citation tracking and insights dashboard are included on Core.
Starting price: $250 per month, Core, billed annually ($300 per month, billed monthly). Free plan: No free plan; 7-day free trial. Skip if your budget is under $250 a month.
Which Goodie alternative fits which need
- Teams that want to test with their own data before paying: AthenaHQ, $295 per month, Starter, 3,600 credits.
- Small brands tracking a few prompts cheaply: Otterly, $29 per month, Lite, 15 prompts ($25 per month, billed annually).
- Marketing teams that want daily tracking across three engines: Peec AI, $95 per month, Starter, 50 prompts ($80 per month, billed annually).
- Brands that want enterprise-grade analytics and content actions: Profound, Pricing on request.
- Teams that want monitoring plus AI crawler analytics: Scrunch, $250 per month, Core, billed annually ($300 per month, billed monthly).
Free plans and trials
Goodie: No free plan; 7-day free trial on Core. The alternatives:
- AthenaHQ: Yes, Essential free tier with a $25 credit.
- Otterly: No free plan; free trial offered.
- Peec AI: No free plan; free trial offered.
- Profound: No free plan; free trial of 50 prompts for 7 days.
- Scrunch: No free plan; 7-day free trial.
What to check before you choose
The same five checks apply to every tool on this page, and they matter more than the starting price.
- Price per tracked prompt. These tools price by prompts, answers or credits. Divide the monthly price by the prompts you can track to compare tools fairly.
- Which AI engines are covered. Coverage of ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Copilot varies by tool and by plan, and some engines cost extra.
- How often answers are checked. AI answers change from run to run. Daily checks give a steadier trend than weekly ones, at a higher price.
- What you can do with the data. Look for cited sources, competitor comparison and guidance on which pages to change, not only a visibility score.
- Countries, languages and seats. Check how many markets, brands and users the plan includes if you work across regions or clients.
What switching from Goodie involves
Switching AI visibility trackers means starting a new baseline. Export your prompt list, tags, competitor set and as much answer and citation history as the tool allows, because the new tool cannot recreate past results. Load the same prompts into the new tool and run both side by side for two to four weeks. Scores will differ, since each tool samples engines differently, so compare the direction of the trend and the sources cited, not the absolute numbers. Rebuild alerts and reports once you trust the new figures. If you are on an annual contract with Goodie, check the renewal date and notice period first.
Mistakes to avoid
Do not switch on headline price alone. The starting prices here use different units (per user, per contact, per site), so price each alternative at your own usage, and check which features sit on the plan you would actually buy.
Quick answers
What is the cheapest alternative here?
Otterly has the lowest published starting price of the 4 options here that charge at a flat monthly rate: $29 per month, Lite, 15 prompts ($25 per month, billed annually). AthenaHQ also has a free plan. Checked 14 November 2026.
AthenaHQ vs Otterly: which one should you choose?
AthenaHQ is the better fit for teams that want to test with their own data before paying. Otterly is the better fit for small brands tracking a few prompts cheaply. AthenaHQ pricing: $295 per month, Starter, 3,600 credits. Otterly pricing: $29 per month, Lite, 15 prompts ($25 per month, billed annually).
Which of these alternatives has a free plan?
AthenaHQ offers a free plan. Otterly, Peec AI, Profound and Scrunch offer a free trial instead. Checked 14 November 2026.
How much does AthenaHQ cost?
AthenaHQ pricing: $295 per month, Starter, 3,600 credits. Free plan: Yes, Essential free tier with a $25 credit. Checked 14 November 2026 against the vendor's own page.
How much does Otterly cost?
Otterly pricing: $29 per month, Lite, 15 prompts ($25 per month, billed annually). Free plan: No free plan; free trial offered. Checked 14 November 2026 against the vendor's own page.
How much does Peec AI cost?
Peec AI pricing: $95 per month, Starter, 50 prompts ($80 per month, billed annually). Free plan: No free plan; free trial offered. Checked 14 November 2026 against the vendor's own page.
Which alternative is best for marketing teams that want daily tracking across three engines?
Peec AI. Pricing: $95 per month, Starter, 50 prompts ($80 per month, billed annually). Free plan: No free plan; free trial offered. Skip if your budget is under $95 a month or you need more than 3 engines on the entry plan.
Which alternative is best for brands that want enterprise-grade analytics and content actions?
Profound. Pricing is on request. Free plan: No free plan; free trial of 50 prompts for 7 days. Skip if you need a published price before talking to sales.
Which alternative is best for teams that want monitoring plus AI crawler analytics?
Scrunch. Pricing: $250 per month, Core, billed annually ($300 per month, billed monthly). Free plan: No free plan; 7-day free trial. Skip if your budget is under $250 a month.
What is the catch with the AthenaHQ free plan?
The free plan covers: Essential free tier with a $25 credit. Paid pricing: $295 per month, Starter, 3,600 credits. Checked 14 November 2026.
Common questions
What is the best alternative to Goodie?
It depends on what you need. AthenaHQ suits teams that want to test with their own data before paying, Otterly suits small brands tracking a few prompts cheaply, and Peec AI suits marketing teams that want daily tracking across three engines.
How much does Goodie cost?
Goodie pricing: $295 per month, Core, 110 prompts. Free plan: No free plan; 7-day free trial on Core. Checked 2026-11-14 against the vendor's page.
Is there a free alternative to Goodie?
Yes. AthenaHQ has a free plan. Check the limits before you rely on one.
How were these Goodie alternatives chosen?
They are the products Adziq already compares alongside Goodie, with prices read from each vendor's pricing page.
Did Adziq test these products?
No. This comparison uses each vendor's published pricing and documentation, checked on the dates shown.
Sources
How we research, check prices and label sponsored listings: editorial policy. To feature a product or agency, ask about a listing.






